Subscribe to Texas Ideas Progress |
Visit this group |
David Lee Hall
Texas Ideas Progress
Saturday, February 12, 2011
David Lee Hall
Electrical Grid Vulnerable
Plano City Taxes
David Smith - Collin County Judge
Ed Kless - Texas Senate District 8
Marines are a Band of Brothers
Education Choice Example
Answers To Questions
Smart Grid Scam
Texas Senate District 8 Announcement
Van Taylor - Texas House District 66
Boundary Change Effects
School Choice Reasons
School District Results
School District Despotism
Civil War - United States of America
Corruption - United States of America
Concerns - United States of America
Follow-up - United States of America
Comments - United States of America
United States of America
Responses to Answers for Dr. John Cooper
Tour the World in Downtown Plano at the PLANO INTERNATIONAL FESTIVAL!
Dr. John Cooper - Candidate for US Congress - Texas Economic Development
Texas Economic Development
Pass For Pay Selected Feedback
Pass For Pay
Texas Health Savings
You Are Invited
Electric Lines Underground
Big Investment Decision
Microbe Hydrogen Production
Starbucks Coffee Company
Methane Availability Generation
Propane Fuel Analysis
Propane Green Representative
Methane Adoption Comments, Answers, & Projections
Methane versus Hydrogen as Fuel
Methane Fuel Cell
War & Peace & Progress
Save Our System
Texas Economy Would Benefit by Abolishing Property Tax
Plano Multi-Cultural Outreach Roundtable
Robert Canright Endorsement
Steve Navarre Endorsement
Lee Dunlap Campaign Answers
Phil Dyer Endorsement
Texas School Finance
Lee Dunlap Endorsement
Thursday, June 17, 2010
Electrical Grid Vulnerable
Smart Grid Proposals supposedly overcome these issues; however, this is logically impossible; since severed or downed lines, destroyed transformers, inoperable generators, software bugs, and numerous other failures can interrupt the smartest electrical grid.
The optimal solution is to provide off-grid options (Smart Generation Systems) including single consumer generators using natural gas which is less prone to interruption and natural gas can even be safely stored by each consumption site for added backup.
Additionally, this is a much more economical use of fuel (fuel cells 60% efficient - downhole muffled turbines 30% efficient) versus about 6% efficiency via the grid. Anyone who is concerned about our carbon footprint (not me but there are many who do have that concern) should help me push for Smart Generation Systems. This approach has the potential to reduce our carbon footprint by an order of magnitude (i.e. 10% of present) along with potential cost savings due to economies of scale in manufacturing, reasonable regulations, and as much as 90% less use of fuel without the electric utility mark-up.
Texas should move as soon as possible into Smart Generation Systems (off-grid) since this should be the future. Texas research grants, manufacturer incentives, and regulatory support should be provided to give private enterprise a clear path to develop these technologies. Please let me know your thoughts.
.
Friday, June 11, 2010
Plano City Taxes
From: Phil Dyer phildyer@plano.gov
Date: Thu, Jun 10, 2010
Subject: RE: David Smith - Collin County Judge
To: David Hall
David: Thank you for the message, and I hope you are doing well.
Let me answer your question---and I hope that the response is not too long.
We have been working on the budget since I was elected in May of '09. There is no question that the budget of Plano has changed---permanently. The growth of the 80's, 90's, and 00's threw off a ton of fees/revenues that fed the city coffers. Well, the growth is over (although we still have a lot of commercial land remaining to be developed), and that source of revenue has diminished.
Our sales tax is down. It will improve when the economy improves, but it won't get back to the levels of 3 or 4 years ago. The new retail in Allen, Frisco, McKinney, etc. is impacting us just as Plano's retail growth in the 80's and 90's impacted Richardson and north Dallas (goodbye to Richardson Square Mall, and Prestonwood Mall). It is the natural progression/evolution as new areas develop.
Right now, commercial real estate valuations are down significantly, which has a strong impact on our ad valorem tax revenue. That will come back, but it may be a couple of years (or more).
So, we are in a bit of a perfect storm in which our largest sources of revenue are all being impacted.
We have cut $20 million out of the budget over the past 18 months, and we are working on more. We have eliminated over 150 positions in the city, permanently.
So, that is the bad news. Now a bit of good news.
We are AAA rated by the bond rating agencies---the highest rating a city can have. They don't give those ratings to cities who are on the verge of a fiscal train wreck. Our city services are second to none---we have nationally accredited departments throughout our city organization. We continue to win all kinds of awards for excellence and/or innovation.
Finally, the city tax burden to the residents of Plano is lower (in most cases far lower) than in our neighboring cities. I am not criticizing those cities. They are well governed and well managed, and they provide good services. I think that we can stand right with them based on our city services. Here is the city tax burden on owners of a $250,000 home in local cities:
Plano $ 977
Allen $1,388
Carrollton $1,236
Dallas $1,496
Frisco $1,162
McKinney $1,464
Richardson $1,438
Ft. Worth $1,710
Arlington $1,296
The percentage difference is consistent at all price levels. So, the more expensive a home, Plano becomes an even larger bargain.
Bottom line is that Plano is a bargain compared to other cities. We could raise our tax rate a lot, and still be cheaper than almost all of the cities shown above.
We are not a fiscal train wreck waiting to happen. We have challenges, but we are working on this every day (literally). People who say this about Plano simply have not done their research. I always welcome the opportunity to visit with people about this. They may still think that the city tax burden is too high, and I respect that position, but let's work with factual information, and then we can make progress.
I always appreciate the fact that you do the research and gather your information before you communicate.
Please let me know if there is anything I can do.
Regards,
Phil
Phil Dyer
From: David Hall#
Sent: Thursday, June 10, 2010
To: Phil Dyer
Subject: Fwd: David Smith - Collin County Judge
Phil,
I have received some feedback stating that "City of Plano is heading for a fiscal train wreck". I would like to respond properly. Please let me know if there is something I do not know or confirm that Plano is in good shape financially.
David
Sunday, June 6, 2010
David Smith - Collin County Judge
David Smith and I agree on 3 important matters:
- Jail is not the proper place for Non-Violent Offenders, Mental Cases, and Homeless Persons
- All non-emergency significant services should have at least 3 bidders before being awarded a contract
- Currently voter approved infrastructure projects should move forward quickly while the cost is lower due to the economy
During Plano City Council service David Smith led in:
- Reduced rate of spending increases during period of rapid growth
- Lowered tax rate - 3 times coupled with strengthened city finances
- Instituted city-wide tax rebate coupled with improved city services
- Plano City Council - 3 Terms
- Plano City Finance Committee - 6 Years
- Manager at EDS
- Church Leader
- US Air Force - Engineering Service - after Engineering Degree from Vanderbilt University
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Ed Kless - Texas Senate District 8
After in person discussions, Ed Kless is my recommendation for Texas Senate District 8, and you should contact him if you have additional questions.
David Hall
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Ed Kless
Date: Tue, Jun 1, 2010 at 8:49 PM
Subject: Ed Kless for Texas Senate District 8
To: David Hall
Dear Mr. Hall,
I have been reading your weekly emails for a while. Since you state that you are considering supporting candidates other than Republicans, I hope you will consider endorsing me. I believe that you and I agree on many issues.
To illustrate this, have inserted my answer to the League of Women Voters for question 1 followed by your responses with my comments for questions 2-7. Although you and I definitely do not agree about everything, based on your writings, I suspect that you do not expect or demand that of anyone.
Thank you for your consideration.
In Liberty,
Ed Kless
Libertarian Candidate for Texas Senate – District 8
http://electkless.com
+1 972 836 9972
1. Please describe the education and experience that qualify you for the position of member of the Texas Senate/House of Representatives.
Ever since graduating magna cum laude from Pace University in New York, I have been working in one capacity or another to help make small businesses better. Within the past decade, I have begun studying economics, especially price theory, and believe that the lack of basic economic understanding drives most bad government policies. There are two words that all economists agree upon regardless of their political leaning, “Incentives matter.” Legislators motivated by the best of intentions have created perverse incentives that interfere with free market activities. Government is the problem in many cases, not the solution.
2. Texas ranks very low among states in percentage of persons with health insurance. What measures would you support for improving access to health care in Texas?
Texas Health Savings Accounts
Maintain database of IRS-qualified HSA expenses.
Enrollees establish HSA at insurance company or thrift.
Enrollees issued debit card.
Providers approve expenses for immediate payment on purchases of covered expense (insurance companies) or qualified expense for which there is adequate savings.
Public money issued as voucher which may be allocated as desired to either pay for insurance and/or be placed in the individual HSA account.
With this approach each individual will make the choice of how their money is spent based on their life situation.
2. I am in favor of large HSAs and catastrophic insurance. Insurance is a financial product and is meant for things we do not want. It is not intended to pay for the mundane. For example, car insurance does not pay for oil changes and gasoline and health insurance should not pay for every doctor visit and routine medical treatment. In addition, if we allow companies to include a heath dividend in policies for younger people, it would reduce the uninsured rates to a manageable level. Lastly, insurance should be allowed to be sold across state lines, this would increase competition.
3. How should Texas finance the construction and maintenance of roads and bridges?
User fees (tolls) collected via license plate numbers. * See Below
Should the gas tax be raised?
It should be eliminated in favor of a sales tax on vehicle fuel.
Should the gas tax be dedicated solely to road construction and maintenance?
If collected then yes.
Do you support increased construction of toll roads?
Yes, provided the tolls are only used for the road on which collected. *
* Also, the Texas law that requires parallel access roads for toll roads should be continued. This is a good law as it respects the poor, avoids coercion to pay the toll, and forces the toll road authority to maintain a high standard or lose business, unlike “Independent” School Districts.
3. I am OK with toll roads and agree the gas tax should be eliminated.
4. Do you consider Texas’ current per-student public school spending to be adequate and equitable? If not, what measures would you support to increase funding of public school education?
Adequate Not Equitable
Parents should have freedom of choice for their children's education. Currently Texas only supports “Independent” School Districts and charter schools. Parents should be free to choose a non-public school alternative and receive the state money for educating their children after their children demonstrate competency for core subjects by:
Student passes computer-based semester exam for each required course at an approved testing center.
Testing centers should be open at flexible times for students throughout the year with students being able to take any specific test for their semester grade level any time the testing center is open.
4. Vouchers, vouchers and vouchers! Senator Shapiro is on a committee figuring out how to raise more money to spend, I would work out a way to reduce the amount of money spent. Testing is a difficult issue as all tests are skewed and can be gamed; I would prefer more local control of the tests. Vouchers would allow parents to judge for themselves if their kids are learning. If they feel they are not, they will move them to a different school.
5. Texas is one of the largest emitters of carbon dioxide in the U.S. What changes would you support to Texas’ energy policies?
Encourage businesses to develop home electric generation systems, cost-effective geothermal heat pumps, and methane/propane powered vehicles with Texas Energy Incentives.
The electric grid is inefficient including: turbines convert about 33% of fuel to electricity; transmission lines lose about 66%; with inefficiencies in dynamos, transformers, and other equipment yields about 6% of fuel energy to homes.
Home generators using natural gas would be considerably more efficient: fuel cells 60%+ or turbines with buried mufflers for noise mitigation 33%+.
Geothermal heat pumps reduce energy required for HVAC.
Methane/propane vehicles could be filled at home and emit less pollutants.
5. I agree that all alternatives should be explored, but with no government help. There is already enough market incentive to develop these technologies if they are truly energy efficient. For example, I have no problem with T. Boone Pickens drilling for all the natural gas in the state of Texas, he just should not get any of our money to do it.
6. State hospitals that serve people with mental illness have reduced the number of available beds, yet the need for services is increasing. How do you propose that Texas provide for the care of those with severe mental illness?
Allow non-violent criminals to remain at home with an ankle tracking system to monitor their location at all times then use the money saved to help persons with mental illness.
6. OK, but I also believe if we reduced the tax burden, local charities would be better able to take care of these folks. Americans, especially Texans are a giving people, but when our tax burden is so high, we just can’t do everything we would like to do locally.
7. What other issues do you believe will be most pressing in the next session of the Texas Legislature, and what is your position on these issues?
Persuade the Federal Government to return the offshore land that belongs to Texas from 10 to 200 miles from shore. Offshore leasing is the second largest source of "Federal Revenue" after income taxes which I learned working as a consultant for the Minerals Management Service.
Some information from the following web addresses is applicable to the offshore income question:
http://www.mms.gov/aboutmms/OCSLA/ocslahistory.htm
http://www.gomr.mms.gov/homepg/lsesale/visual1.pdf
This change can be effected cooperating with other states or the courts.
Replace property taxes with higher sales taxes.
Bring pressure on Texas State Agencies to hire Texas based businesses starting with replacing Pearson for student end-of-course evaluation testing.
7. I like the idea of taking revenue back from the Feds. It is always better to keep the money closer to the source. I would also eliminate property taxes, but would not increase the sales tax. Government must get smaller.
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Marines are a Band of Brothers
Toward the end of the reception, this Marine and I were able to visit for a while. He and Van went through Infantry Officer Course, Sniper Officer Course, and Military Intelligence Officer Basic Course before serving in First Marine Regiment as platoon commanders together. He stated that he and Van became close friends even though there are some differences.
Van's friend explained that he is a Mustang (served as enlisted Marine then was commissioned) whereas Van was a college graduate. Also Van's friend is from New York City whereas Van is a lifelong Texan and he is older than Van since he spent time working up to sergeant in addition to getting his college degree whereas Van was graduated from Harvard after only 3 years. Regardless of their differences, Van and the Marine became close friends, and he would like to come to Texas when he retires from the Marine Corps to a great extent because of Van's influence.
While serving together in the Marine Corps, they recognized that they could depend on each other, share a common love for the USA, and care about people. Not surprisingly, those were some of the same attributes that Congressman Jeb Hensarling mentioned in his speech endorsing Van for State Representative. Congressman Hensarling also listed Van’s excellent conservative endorsements: Texans for Fiscal Responsibility, Young Conservatives of Texas, and the Texas Alliance for Life. Van is also A rated with the NRA and Tea Approved by the North Texas Tea Party -- i.e Van is the true conservative in this race.
This Friday (February 26th) is the last day to vote early and next Tuesday March 2, 2010 is primary election day. If you have not voted yet then please accomplish that so your preferences will count. Also, please vote for Van who has waged a positive campaign of explaining his plans for improving Texas, reducing taxes, and looking out for our interests as he has done while serving us in the past.
.
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
USA Education Results
http://www.nces.ed.gov/ _____ http://www.manhattan-institute.org/ _____ http://www.act.org/
http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/act-sat-concordance-tables.pdf
http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/cbs-2009-Table-3_Mean-SAT-CR-MATH-and-Writing-Scores-by-State.pdf
It is obvious from this table that spending more money with the current approaches does not yield better results.
For example: 3 of the biggest spenders have some of the lowest graduation rates / College Readiness Results: i.e. New York $13k - 67.4%, Alaska $12k - 66.5%, & Washington D.C. $11k - 65.4%; while, 6 States spending close to or below the National Average have over 80% graduation rates with relatively high College Readiness Results: i.e. Iowa $10k - 86.9%, Minnesota $9.5k - 86.2%, South Dakota $10k - 84.5%, Missouri $9k - 81%, Idaho $8k - 80.5, & Arkansas $10k - 80.4%.
Furthermore, the highest graduation rate of 87.5% would not be acceptable for a high achiever in any other pursuit, the 73.4% national graduation rate shows that we are not building an educated Nation, and the 11 failing states with under 70% graduation rates are bringing everyone down even more.
Freedom of Education Choice does work for instance in Sweden http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/points/stories/DN-mccleskey_17edi.State.Edition1.270ad18.html where practically everyone is graduated from high school. Currently only Independent School Districts and Charter School receive any State financial support. My suggestion for providing Freedom of Education Choice http://texas-ideas-progress.blogspot.com/2009/09/pass-for-pay.html would provide parents financial resources to make informed choices for their children's education if they wish while limiting State interference to evaluating results.
___________________________________________________ _College Bound Preparation Testing
__________________ $'s per Student _________ 2005–06 ______ S _ ---------------------------------------
____________________ Adjusted for _____ Averaged Freshman _ A _ Graduates__ SAT Score or __ % Above or
State _____________ Cost of Living _____ Graduation Rate __ T _ % Tested __ACT Equivalent _ (Below) Avg
--------------- ----------- ____ ------------ __- _------- _----------- _ ---------
Vermont _________ 15,139 __________ 82.3 ______ X __ 64% _____ 1036 ________ +2%
Wyoming _________ 14,126 __________ 76.1 ______ - __ 80% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
New Jersey ______ 13,238 __________ 84.8 ______ X __ 76% _____ 1009 ________ (1%)
New York ________ 13,064 __________ 67.4 ______ X __ 85% ______ 987 ________ (3%)
Maine ___________ 12,985 __________ 76.3 ______ X __ 90% ______ 935 ________ (8%)
Rhode Island ____ 12,478 __________ 77.8 ______ X __ 66% ______ 994 ________ (2%)
Alaska __________ 12,090 __________ 66.5 ______ X __ 46% _____ 1036 ________ +2%
Connecticut _____ 11,885 __________ 80.9 ______ X __ 83% _____ 1022 ________ +1%
Montana _________ 11,660 __________ 81.9 ______ - __ 56% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Massachusetts ___ 11,545 __________ 79.5 ______ X __ 84% _____ 1040 ________ +2%
Delaware ________ 11,426 __________ 76.3 ______ X __ 71% ______ 993 ________ (2%)
Pennsylvania ____ 11,252 __________ 83.5 ______ X __ 71% ______ 994 ________ (2%)
Washington D.C. _ 11,193 __________ 65.4 ______ X __ 79% ______ 917 _______ (10%)
New Hampshire ___ 11,169 __________ 81.1 ______ X __ 75% _____ 1046 ________ (3%)
West Virginia ___ 11,150 __________ 76.9 ______ - __ 64% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
Nebraska ________ 11,023 __________ 87.0 ______ - __ 72% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
North Dakota ____ 10,885 __________ 82.1 ______ - __ 81% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Wisconsin _______ 10,529 __________ 87.5 ______ - __ 67% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Hawaii __________ 10,426 __________ 75.5 ______ X __ 58% ______ 981 ________ (3%)
South Dakota ____ 10,223 __________ 84.5 ______ - __ 77% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Kansas __________ 10,216 __________ 77.6 ______ - __ 74% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Ohio ____________ 10,119 __________ 79.2 ______ - __ 65% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
Maryland ________ 10,088 __________ 79.9 ______ X __ 69% _____ 1002 ________ (1%)
Indiana _________ 10,053 __________ 73.3 ______ X __ 63% _____ 1003 ________ (1%)
Iowa _____________ 9,977 __________ 86.9 ______ - __ 60% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
National Averages_ 9,963 __________ 73.4 ______ X __ --- _____ 1016 _________ 0%
Michigan _________ 9,809 __________ 72.2 ______ - _ 100% ______ 950 ________ (6%)
Louisiana ________ 9,787 __________ 59.5 ______ - __ 88% ______ 950 ________ (6%)
Arkansas _________ 9,756 __________ 80.4 ______ - __ 74% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
New Mexico _______ 9,525 __________ 67.3 ______ - __ 63% ______ 950 ________ (6%)
Minnesota ________ 9,476 __________ 86.2 ______ - __ 69% _____ 1070 ________ +5%
Oregon ___________ 9,460 __________ 73.0 ______ X __ 52% _____ 1048 ________ +3%
Missouri _________ 9,146 __________ 81.0 ______ - __ 69% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
South Carolina ___ 9,008 __________ 61.0 ______ X __ 67% ______ 982 ________ (3%)
Illinois _________ 8,829 __________ 79.7 ______ - __ 98% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
Alabama __________ 8,769 __________ 66.2 ______ - __ 77% ______ 950 ________ (6%)
Georgia __________ 8,754 __________ 62.4 ______ X __ 71% ______ 981 ________ (3%)
Virginia _________ 8,725 __________ 74.5 ______ X __ 68% _____ 1023 ________ +1%
Kentucky _________ 8,681 __________ 77.2 ______ - __ 72% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
Mississippi ______ 8,635 __________ 63.5 ______ - __ 92% ______ 910 _______ (10%)
Colorado _________ 8,514 __________ 75.5 ______ - _ 100% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
Florida __________ 8,437 __________ 63.6 ______ X __ 59% ______ 995 ________ (2%)
Oklahoma _________ 8,255 __________ 77.8 ______ - __ 70% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
Idaho ____________ 8,034 __________ 80.5 ______ - __ 58% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
North Carolina ___ 7,835 __________ 71.8 ______ X __ 63% _____ 1006 ________ (1%)
Washington _______ 7,688 __________ 72.9 ______ X __ 53% _____ 1055 ________ +4%
Tennessee ________ 7,620 __________ 70.6 ______ - __ 88% ______ 990 ________ (3%)
California _______ 7,571 __________ 69.2 ______ X __ 49% _____ 1013 ________ (0%)
Texas ____________ 7,561 __________ 72.5 ______ X __ 51% ______ 992 ________ (2%)
Nevada ___________ 7,213 __________ 55.8 ______ X __ 42% _____ 1006 ________ (1%)
Arizona __________ 7,112 __________ 70.5 ______ X __ 26% _____ 1037 ________ +2%
Utah _____________ 5,964 __________ 78.6 ______ - __ 68% _____ 1030 ________ +1%
.
Monday, January 18, 2010
Education Choice Examples
The link above is my suggestion for implementing Texas School Choice.
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/germany/7080790/German-homeschoolers-granted-political-asylum-in-US.html
Published: 12:46AM GMT 27 Jan 2010
German homeschoolers granted political asylum in US
A German couple who fled to America so they could homeschool their children have been granted political asylum by a US immigration judge.
The decision, announced Tuesday in Memphis, clears the way for Uwe Romeike, his wife and five children to stay in Tennessee, where they have been living since 2008. German state constitutions require children to attend public or private schools, and parents can face fines or prison time if they do not comply.
Mr Romeike, an evangelical Christian, said he believes the German curriculum is "against Christian values". Mike Donnelly, a lawyer with the Home School Legal Defence Association advocacy group, said he hoped the ruling will influence public opinion in German
www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/points/stories/DN-mccleskey_17edi.State.Edition1.270ad18.html
Clayton McCleskey: An education system more American than America's
04:18 PM CST on Friday, January 15, 2010
BÃ…STAD, Sweden – While Texas is struggling to lift sagging standards in its public education system, Sweden's schools are rockin' and rollin'.
But Sweden's approach to education is culturally all-American. The Swedish model encourages competition and empowers individuals to take responsibility for their own education.
Ironically, in contrast to our sky-is-the-limit mentality, Swedish culture stresses lagom, which roughly translates as "just enough" or "moderation." The Swedes focus on the collective good and equality. Americans are ruggedly individualistic and savor competition.
However our one-size-fits-all public education system leaves students in Dallas with less choice and opportunity than their counterparts in Stockholm. That needs to change.
The Swedish model is built on two pillars of choice: a voucher system at both the primary and secondary levels and varied high school tracks.
Let's start with the voucher program. If a public school isn't meeting a student's needs, he or she can leave. Students have the option to switch to another public school or they can leave the public system altogether and opt for a private school, explained Fredric Skälstad, political adviser to the Swedish minister of education.
The government attaches money to each student, which then follows him wherever he goes. Students with special needs – such as those from non-Swedish-speaking backgrounds – receive extra money.
If a public school isn't up to snuff, students leave. And they take their money with them.
In an interview released by the Pacific Research Institute, Stockholm County governor and former education minister Per Unckel explained: "Choice is for everyone, whatever income you have. The right of the kid is to get a good education. If the public sector cannot offer it, he or she should have the right to go somewhere else."
Skälstad told me that when Sweden introduced the voucher system in the early '90s, it was controversial. But it's now widely popular, and the results have shown rising standards across the board.
The program has also helped desegregate schools in cities with large immigrant populations, such as Stockholm.
"It's a way for the high achievers to get out of the environment that is holding them back," Skälstad said.
"You can change your situation. You do not just go to a certain school because a bureaucrat drew a line on a map. This is a way for everyone to be able to make something out of themselves."
The second pillar of choice piggy-backs off the voucher system to allow high schoolers to choose from a smorgasbord of high school programs centered on three paths: college preparatory, vocational and a more remedial track.
So, Swedish students go to schools they like and are able to follow their interests and passions. A prime example of this is the Apelryd high school here in this small town on Sweden's southeastern coast. It's a private school specializing in music, fashion and design, sports and culinary arts. The facilities are top-notch and rival the best private schools in Dallas.
But the voucher system means that students here can attend such state-of-the-art private schools without having to pay tuition.
Cecilia Weidrup – the school's guidance counselor – raved about Apelryd, calling it a "very special place." She told me the teachers and students love it, a statement supported by the smiles on the faces of pupils and instructors alike.
Last fall, I visited a high school near the Arctic Circle that trains students to be pilots, and I was struck by how motivated students were. That's probably because they all chose to be there. In Sweden, it's like every high school is a magnet school, offering specialized programs to recruit students, since schools compete with each other.
The U.S. has the best higher education system in the world in great part because universities compete for survival. But when it comes to primary and secondary education, we have public schools run by slow-moving bureaucracies that face little competition. Our schools frequently fail to meet student needs, whether they want to go to college or become a mechanic.
Passionately egalitarian Sweden uses vouchers to ensure that all students have an opportunity to achieve. But in the U.S., we deny students control over their education and often lock them into under-performing schools where they are unable to follow their dreams.
That seems pretty un-American to me.
Some may question whether the Swedish model could work in the U.S. But Lance Izumi, senior director of education studies at the Pacific Research Institute, argued that such doubts are misguided. "There isn't anything that discounts the Swedish model as something the U.S. can't look at," he said.
After all, isn't it strange that Sweden has a more American education system than we do?
Clayton M. McCleskey is a Points staff writer based in Germany, where he is a Fulbright journalism scholar. His e-mail address is cmccleskey@dallasnews.com
Thursday, January 14, 2010
Answers To Questions
The other person on the ballot hired some lawyers to protest my candidacy. Unfortunately, I did not withdraw from Precinct Chairman in writing within the time allowed which was earlier than the filing date. Therefore, I will be on the ballot unopposed for Precinct Chairman even though I had originally been removed from the ballot for that position.
1. Please describe the education and experience that qualify you for the position of member of the Texas Senate.
I am a member of McDermott Road Church of Christ in Plano, have been married to the same woman for 38 years, we have 3 children & 8 grandchildren, I served as an officer in the Marine Corps 1972-1976 with final rank of Captain, am an alumnus of Abilene Christian University and Price Waterhouse Big 4 CPA Firm, worked in Petroleum Industry / Management Consulting / Texas Public Education, served as a Republican Party Precinct Chairman & Publicity Director for the Plano Multi-Cultural Outreach Roundtable, and have posted ideas weekly online with public feedback for over two years.
2. Texas ranks very low among states in percentage of persons with health insurance. What measures would you support for improving access to health care in Texas?
Texas Health Savings Accounts
Maintain database of IRS-qualified HSA expenses.
Enrollees establish HSA at insurance company or thrift.
Enrollees issued debit card.
Providers approve expenses for immediate payment on purchases of covered expense (insurance companies) or qualified expense for which there is adequate savings.
Public money issued as voucher which may be allocated as desired to either pay for insurance and/or be placed in the individual HSA account.
With this approach each individual will make the choice of how their money is spent based on their life situation.
3. How should Texas finance the construction and maintenance of roads and bridges?
User fees (tolls) collected via license plate numbers. * See Below
Should the gas tax be raised?
It should be eliminated in favor of a sales tax on vehicle fuel.
Should the gas tax be dedicated solely to road construction and maintenance?
If collected then yes.
Do you support increased construction of toll roads?
Yes, provided the tolls are only used for the road on which collected. *
* Also, the Texas law that requires parallel access roads for toll roads should be continued. This is a good law as it respects the poor, avoids coercion to pay the toll, and forces the toll road authority to maintain a high standard or lose business, unlike “Independent” School Districts.
4. Do you consider Texas’ current per-student public school spending to be adequate and equitable? If not, what measures would you support to increase funding of public school education?
Adequate Not Equitable
Parents should have freedom of choice for their children's education. Currently Texas only supports “Independent” School Districts and charter schools. Parents should be free to choose a non-public school alternative and receive the state money for educating their children after their children demonstrate competency for core subjects by:
Student passes computer-based semester exam for each required course at anTesting centers should be open at flexible times for students throughout the year with students being able to take any specific test for their semester grade level any time the testing center is open.
approved testing center.
5. Texas is one of the largest emitters of carbon dioxide in the U.S. What changes would you support to Texas’ energy policies?
Encourage businesses to develop home electric generation systems, cost-effective geothermal heat pumps, and methane/propane powered vehicles with Texas Energy Incentives.
The electric grid is inefficient including: turbines convert about 33% of fuel to electricity; transmission lines lose about 66%; with inefficiencies in dynamos, transformers, and other equipment yields about 6% of fuel energy to homes.
Home generators using natural gas would be considerably more efficient: fuel cells 60%+ or turbines with buried mufflers for noise mitigation 33%+.
Geothermal heat pumps reduce energy required for HVAC.
Methane/propane vehicles could be filled at home and emit less pollutants.
6. State hospitals that serve people with mental illness have reduced the number of available beds, yet the need for services is increasing. How do you propose that Texas provide for the care of those with severe mental illness?
Allow non-violent criminals to remain at home with an ankle tracking system to monitor their location at all times then use the money saved to help persons with mental illness.
7. What other issues do you believe will be most pressing in the next session of the Texas Legislature, and what is your position on these issues?
Persuade the Federal Government to return the offshore land that belongs to Texas from 10 to 200 miles from shore. Offshore leasing is the second largest source of "Federal Revenue" after income taxes which I learned working as a consultant for the Minerals Management Service.
Some information from the following web addresses is applicable to the offshore income question:
http://www.mms.gov/aboutmms/OCSLA/ocslahistory.htm
http://www.gomr.mms.gov/homepg/lsesale/visual1.pdf
This change can be effected cooperating with other states or the courts.
Replace property taxes with higher sales taxes.
Bring pressure on Texas State Agencies to hire Texas based businesses starting with replacing Pearson for student end-of-course evaluation testing.
Friday, January 1, 2010
Smart Grid Scam
Texas Senate District 8 Announcement
The things I would like to accomplish serving in the Texas Senate include the following:
- Meet publicly at least quarterly with groups of Constituents to receive input while continuing to publish weekly emails offering information, requesting input, and providing a forum.
- Persuade the Federal Government to return the offshore land that belongs to Texas further out to 200 miles rather than the current 10 mile limit since offshore leasing is the second largest source of "Federal Revenue" after income taxes.
- Work with other Texas Law Makers to eliminate property taxes.
- Introduce legislation to improve health care for Texans starting with Public School Teachers.
- Help Texas give back more control to Parents of their Children's Education through various reforms including the Texas Education Agency.
- Bring pressure on Texas State Agencies to hire Texas based businesses.
- Encourage Texas businesses to develop home electric generation systems, cost-effective geothermal heat pumps, and methane/propane powered vehicles with Texas Energy Incentives.
I am a member of McDermott Road Church of Christ in Plano, have been married to the same woman for 38 years, we have 3 children & 8 grandchildren, I served as an officer in the Marine Corps 1972-1976 with final rank of Captain, am an alumnus of Abilene Christian University and Price Waterhouse Big 4 CPA Firm, worked in Petroleum Industry / Management Consulting / Texas Public Education, and am a Republican Party Precinct Chairman & Publicity Director for the Plano Multi-Cultural Outreach Roundtable.
There is additional information about me, my beliefs, and suggested approaches at http://www.dhall-planoisd.blogspot.com/ and http://www.texas-ideas-progress.blogspot.com/. Also, I am willing to correspond, meet, and speak based on your requests. Please let me know your thoughts.
David Lee Hall
.Tuesday, December 29, 2009
Van Taylor - Texas House District 66
You can reach Van at Van Taylor
I look forward to hearing more from Van about things he believes Texas State Government should do to improve life for Texans, the DFW area, and Plano.
Saturday, December 19, 2009
Boundary Change Effects
According to http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/121709dnplboundaries.414ffdb.html the Plano ISD Board made a unanimous decision on school boundary changes in a series of closed door meetings that were not open to the public but had less than a quorum present. Several years ago, the Texas Attorney General's Staff taught a course for Economic Development Board Members in which I was a student. At that training session I asked specifically about holding closed meetings with less than a quorum in each meeting to discuss difficult issues. The strong response to my question was that this is illegal because it has the cumulative effect of a quorum; however, the Dallas Morning News stated that what was done is within the letter of the law; therefore, it is possible at that training session there was some misunderstanding, miscommunication, or the law may have changed due to court rulings. This type of thing is why we need School Choice.
About the quorum, they may have had a proxy from those that were notThe issue is that any Board Meeting(s) to discuss Plano ISD issues that has a quorum present must be open to the public including with sufficient public notice. However, if a quorum is not present for a meeting then it does not have to be public.
present.
According to http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/121709dnplboundaries.414ffdb.html there was a series of private meetings without a quorum present to discuss the Boundary Issues.
My understanding based on the course I attended presented by the Texas Attorney General is that this has the same effect as a single meeting with a quorum; therefore, those meetings should have been open to the public. I don't plan to pursue this any further, because there is no apparent benefit, but anyone affected has the right to bring this issue to the attention of the Texas Attorney General.
I see your point. I have no issue with the changes, however I can see this process being a problem if the issue was more serious. Thank you for shining attention to this matter.-
For some people these changes were a major issue. Ask any Plano Realtor, they will tell you that school boundaries affect property values, and for people with children in Plano ISD that suffer the changes this issue is very serious. This type of thing is why we need School Choice.
.
Wednesday, December 9, 2009
School Choice Reasons
Below are other notes about Plano ISD with my reaction inserted below each:
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Robert Canright recanright@gmail.com
Date: Dec 8,
2009 10:27 PM
Subject: 5th circuit court
To: David Lee Hall dhall.texas@gmail.com
This is another example of why there should be school choice. Most people would not want our tax dollars spent on these frivilous lawsuits. However, because there is no school choice then we are saddled with needless expenditures like the example above.David,
Because you are interested in education I thought you'd find this story of some interest.I called my daughter in Lubbock during the Big 12 Championship to talk football and she asked me what was going on in Plano. She said many people were coming to her and saying things like, "Lauren, I'm so sorry to hear that the Plano schools are anti-Christian. It must have been horrible being a Christian and going to school in Plano." She asked me why kids from all over Texas suddenly think Plano schools persecute Christians.
I googled around a bit and found this article:
http://www.wfaa.com/home/Court-sides-with-district-in-Plano-candy-cane-suit-78395167.html
"Court sides with district in Plano candy cane suit"
by ASSOCIATED PRESS - Posted on December 3, 2009
You'll remember that years ago the Plano ISD took candy from children at Christmas because it was deemed to be Christian candy. There were also pencils confiscated that had this message: "Jesus is the reason for the season". So now the Plano ISD has won its case in the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, but lost its reputation around the state of Texas.
Instead of having a school district respected around the state for academic excellence, we are now perceived as persecuting Christians. This is a perfect example of how one can lose by winning. The PISD won in court, but has lost in public opinion.
I think the PISD Board of Trustees should never had let things get so out of hand. What do you think?
Robert
David:
Some people have suggested that you may have data sources to which you can provide links where I might secure valid statistics on the percentage of children of K-12 age in Plano that are home-schooled. I would sure appreciate receiving any links you might have.
Thanks,
Anyone who knows the information requested above please let me know. PISD has information on the number of students that have withdrawn to homeschool; however, you will have to complete a freedom of information request to obtain that information; and furthermore, if someone never enrolls then they will obviously not be counted. Another related issue is that a big part of the discrepency between the TEA dropout numbers and the actual numbers are homeschooled students; however, many or probably most of those students are simply dropouts that use homeschool as a way for them and PISD to avoid truancy court; therefore, I think the actual percentage of homeschooled students is not available from any source.
.
Friday, December 4, 2009
School District Results
You mentioned " Plano ISD is the highest" in regards to the amount of money spent per student by school districts. What's the number? I did not see any statistics? Where can someone find these numbers?
The statistics for the costs of direct instruction are presented at http://texas-ideas-progress.blogspot.com/2009/04/robert-canright-endorsement.html. Robert Canright got this information from the Texas Education Agency website http://www.tea.state.tx.us/. There is information about graduation rates at http://planoblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2009/06/study-says-plano-isds-class-of.html.
David – I think you are advocating anarchy – with every person choosing to do what he or she wants and no one making any decisions for the “corporate body of people”. I have lived in a foreign country that required some of this individual decision making and believe me, it was not very effective nor efficient. Democracy is based on an educated an electorate that hopefully acts for the benefit of the country, state, school district, etc. Sometimes what is best for the individual is not best for the group.If the current public school systems were effective then I would agree with you. However, the results speak for themselves. Below is a table showing the graduation rates for various entities.
Ex: a convict professes innocence but is convicted by a jury. Laws (passed by elected officials) require that he be restrained from mingling with the public. What is best for that individual (to go free) is probably not best for the community (assuming his guilt is valid).
Entity / Graduation Rate
USA / 69%
New Jersey / 82%
Texas / 65%
Nevada / 47%
http://planoblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2009/06/study-says-plano-isds-class-of.html
Plano / 78%
Allen / 95%
We already have language anarchy which is causing problems as follows:
- We grant drivers' licenses to people who cannot communicate in English so those people cause major problems when there is an accident, are stopped for a traffic violation, or need directions.
- We provide voting in foreign languages to people who cannot communicate in English which begs the question of how they got their USA citizenship.
- We allow students to move to the next grade in school even though their English is not adequate for their grade level by providing them language assistance instead of English instruction. The people hurt the most by this approach are Hispanics and other minorities that have very high dropout rates. Whereas, Asians who insist on their young people learning English very well have the lowest dropout rate.
Allowing people to make educational choices is more like allowing people to purchase various types of apples. No government official (in the USA) specifies how many, what type, or where apples will be produced or purchased. But many types of apples are readily available here from numerous sources; whereas, in nations (which I have visited) where apples are controlled there are shortages, a lack of varieties, and high prices.
Furthermore, the technology I am proposing for testing students (Pass For Pay) has been used for many years on college entrance, academic achievement, and professional certification exams. Allowing families to make educational choices will have the same results as the freedom we enjoy in choosing apples. Our current educational system has the same effects as is experienced in nations that limit apple choices.
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Robert Canright recanright@gmail.com
Date: Dec 4, 2009 9:34 PM
Subject: Re: School Campus Choice
To: David Hall dhall.planoisd@gmail.com
The public schools have been an un-fixable mess for decades.
The Nation at Risk report came out in 1983 & the schools are still a mess.
We need freedom of choice in education.
Why do we have freedom of choice for killing babies in the womb but not freedom of choice in schools?
This is lunacy!
Robert
.
Saturday, November 28, 2009
School District Despotism
School District Despotism is exemplified by the current campus boundary changes being dictated by Plano ISD. Something as important as which campus a student will attend should not be left to school administrations, elected boards, or even registered voters. Parents should be allowed to select campuses for their children.
Furthermore, the amount of money spent per student by school districts (Plano ISD is the highest in this area) would be more effective if parents were allowed to make decisions on the entity (or entities) to provide their children's education. There are other Government Economic Despotism's that take our money, then decide how it will be spent, and often disallow other choices. There some things that are natural limited choices which are necessary, but when there are good options for allowing people to make their own choices, then people should be allowed to make their own choices with the money allocated.
Too often, natural limited choices eventually no longer make sense because of improved technologies, but the programs continue because of vested interests. Examples of this include: school districts, higher education, post office, health insurance, drug prescriptions, health providers, and communications (AT&T was broken up but regulations keep vestiges of this monopoly going). The coming emails will address some of these examples beginning with school districts.
One response to the information above is inserted below:
Hello David, I was just talking to a Plano mom who has a soon to be a junior high student. She told me that a parent can request their school of choice, although it can be difficult to get the school you choose for your child. They are in the middle of the boundary dispute.
My understanding is also that a parent can choose; however, there is a $50 fee, the student can be sent back if there is any discipline required, there is a one year UIL ineligibility (no participation on inter-school competition - e.g. sports, band, choir, debate, etc.), the school of choice does not increase size based on requests for enrollment, and siblings are not automatically allowed to enroll. Therefore, the choice is not exactly free, open, or welcome.
An obvious question is "what is wrong with those restrictions" and the answers are inserted below.
Fee - Requiring a fee makes changing schools out of the reach of lower income families.
Discipline - There is the potential for school leaders to incite discipline problems to remove students with low scores on the TAKS (standardized test used, I believe wrongly, to evaluate teachers, campuses, and districts).
UIL - University Interscholastic League rules prohibit students from participation in inter-school competitions for one year after transferring to prevent schools from recruiting talented students. This one year wait is onerous for students that only have a short time in school, want to enjoy participating, and risk losing the potential benefits of participation including possible scholarships which again impacts low income families the most.
Enlargement - Campuses people desire should be expanded, campuses people do not want to attend should be reduced in size, and campuses that do not serve well should be either shut down, outsourced, and ceded to a different district.
Siblings - Not allowing an entire family to attend the same campus is a burden which again impacts low income students the most.
Saturday, November 21, 2009
Civil War - United States of America
David,
Thanks for the updates. I find the entire issue both disconcerting and
alarming. For all those conspiracy theorists out there I would think it is a lot
easier to control and amass one government previously that were three of them.
The cultural difference too would be an issue. Canada has language
issues similar to us and unless you also demand a single unifying language, you
won't have a strong nation that is a melting pot, but a mixed salad of confusion
and problems further weakening a nation.
Thanks,
The fact is that NAFTA has been around for a while. NAFTA is a big step toward unification, but with the European Union approach, instead of a uniquely American approach. Also, it does not help the average American and many businesses are not able to move into Mexico or Canada from the USA.
Americans are reluctant to travel through Mexico because of well founded safety concerns. There are many Americans that would like to open businesses in Mexico, retire to Mexico, or vacation away from the main resorts. All of those things are problems for us. One Nation with Canada and Mexico as states would open opportunities for the people of all 3 Nations while giving the People of those Nations input on their National government.
I agree with you on the importance of good communications. Having a single language for the USA is important right now even without any merger. There are simple ways to move to one language.
I proposed one approach for moving to a single language for the USA while running for Plano ISD School Board http://dhall-planoisd.blogspot.com/2008/06/focus-on-english.html. Basically it is to require students lacking standard American (English) proficiency, regardless of background, to work on that alone before moving on to other subjects. Furthermore, we are doing students a disservice by not requiring them to learn English. This is one of the reasons for the high dropout rate. I'm not certain how we moved into the approach of not requiring English but it needs to be changed.
Additionally, there is no reason to provide voting in Spanish or any other language. We need to encourage everyone to learn English but especially our own citizens. Many other Nations require English as part of the basic curriculum so much more should we do the same.
The Civil War was decided mostly based on the larger population, greaterThe 3 additional factors in the comment above have merit. Also, this comment does not mention "superior people" as one of the reasons for victory. So it confirms the main purpose of my list of factors to make the point that "inferior people" was not one of the reasons that Native Americans or the Southern Confederacy lost their wars.
industrialization, and the superior Navy of the North rather than the "greater
unity, more adaptiveness, and superior technology" that you stated.
Genetic Adam and Eve never met because genetic Eve lived 63,000 years priorAccording to the Bible, all men after the Flood are the descendants of Noah (thus he is "genetic Adam"), and Noah was born over 1,600 years after Eve, but Noah had 3 sons who married women from various backgrounds. Therefore, the Bible and Science agree that genetic Eve was born many years before genetic Adam (Noah). Although the timescales are different, the order is the same in that Noah lived much later than Eve, and the percentage time difference is in the same range. Finally, the point is that all people have a shared ancestry which is true according to the Bible and Science, and although there are some differences in people, there is no such thing as superior or inferior people.
to genetic Adam (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/sci/tech/999030.stm) instead of being husband and wife as protrayed in the Bible.
I liked the comment that called you nuts because I thought your merger idea was nutty until you raised so many good points that I realized your idea is not nutty. Even though it seems far-fetched, its not as crazy as what Congress has done this last year or two.Inviting Mexico and Canada to become States is neighborly, logical, and necessary.
I do now worry that American imperialists who like invading other countries might look at Mexico in a new light. It would be a lot easier to invade and conquer Mexico than Iran or Iraq. Mexico has oil and would be easier to exploit than Iraq.
I can imagine our imperialists wanting to invade Mexico as a humanitarian gesture. Let's be careful about making designs on Mexico.
Hi David,
Thanks once again for the opportunity to comment. US, Mexico, Canada unification is I think unrealistic. For starters I think it obvious that there are serious dysfunctional elements with the Mexican government, and the Canadian government would need to make a substantial shift away from socialism. Heck, the government even censors news media in Canada. I won't take time to go into all of the reasons I could think of for now, unification is certainly not a realistic idea.
I do not accept the fact that we are not controlling our borders as any justification for moving on this idea. That problem has a very simple fix and with a law that is already on the books. It is the Federal training certification that allows local, county, and state law enforcement personnel to arrest and detain suspect illegals for the Immigration Service to deal with. There are very few areas that participate in that program now and some that have dropped out. I do feel that with this one issue, local
participation could make a profound difference very quickly. ICE would be quickly overwhelmed and the problem would be brought into the light of day for all to see. This would also take away the excuse that local authorities use to avoid dealing with them unless they are serious felons.
All very good points. Although, the application of border control by local authorities is inherently inconsistent. Furthermore, the fact is that unification is moving forward right now without input from us or the citizens of Canada or Mexico. NAFTA is controlled by career government employees from all 3 Nations. Not fully integrating simply empowers the government instead of us.
.
Saturday, November 14, 2009
Corruption - United States of America
Although I am seeing this idea for the first time, I think it is a fascinating question--a good one for student debates and adult discussions. I would think that ultimately this really may come to pass. chances are, not in my lifetime.
Thank you!
David,My ancestors were some of those people that settled what is now the western USA including Texas, but I also have at least one ancestor that was a Native American, and going back far enough we all have the same 2 ancestors (this is true whether you want Biblical or scientific proof). The advantages the settlers had 150 years ago were greater unity, more adaptiveness, and superior technology. The same generation that formed Texas, forced Sam Houston out of office when he opposed secession from the Union at the beginning of the Civil War against states that had greater unity, more adaptiveness, and superior technology. The USA Civil War resulted in almost half of all American combatant war deaths of all our wars combined and counting civilian deaths is still more costly than all of our other wars combined.
This is about the most hare-brained thing I have read in a very long time. Especially the following paragraph:Mexico will change if it becomes part of the USA. Fair elections, rule of
law, and increased opportunities will work wonders as people accomplish
improvements. To see the difference, look at Texas, California, Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah, and Nevada that were all previously part of Mexico. Americans will move into Mexico (and Canada) in great numbers once there is the USA protection, laws, and opportunities which is also part of what changed those 7 states.
You must understand that the Americans who settled the Western US a hundred and fifty years ago were of a far different breed than the Americans of today. Those people tamed the west because they were as hard as the land itself, and brooked no opposition to their established ways, and sense of "manifest destiny". They felt superior in every way to the indigenous peoples they encountered, and subjugated them (and the land) with total ruthlessness. It took a brutality of mind and muscle unseen in today's Americans to accomplish what was done in the Western US back then.
It cannot, and will not be done by the soft, dependent people who call themselves Americans in the 21st century.You have also got to know that there is absolutely no political will amongst the American people to merge with our neighbors. Especially with Mexico. As a people, we are on the verge of losing all that we hold dear in America, through the rising tyranny in Washington DC.
If there's something worth talking about, it's how we're going to wrest control of our nation's government from the leftist agents who've taken it over.
best regards,
Every generation has its challenges, accomplishments, and mistakes. Historical views change over time, and even with changes there is no consensus, except that it is good to study history to gain perspective on the present. Each generation must do the best possible based on their current situation, knowledge, and technology. Our current situation is that we are not doing well at controlling our land borders with Mexico (1,952 miles) and Canada (5,525 miles); and there is significant trade with both Mexico and Canada that is hampered by the controls in place; therefore, there is agreement that the current system needs improvement.
Bringing Mexico and Canada under the USA umbrella is happening regardless of the wishes of the people of these 3 Nations due to our co-location in North America, dependence on each other, and long borders. Mexico's problems will increasingly spill over into the USA, Canada's immigration policies will increasingly affect the USA, and the USA will continue to attract immigrants from both Mexico and Canada. We should take control of our destiny, opportunities, and economies by merging rather than allowing career government employees in the 3 Nations to determine how this will happen.
The situation for the residents of our ghettos are much better than in most other nations including the opportunities for improvement. Living in poverty is not desirable, but given a choice, I would pick poverty in the USA over any other Nation. I have traveled to every State in the USA as well as many locations outside of the USA so my views are based on some experience as well as information from other people and various sources. There are things being done to make improvements in the USA, and the situation now is much improved over the past, but there is much more we could do to make improvements which I believe will eventually happen.The culture of corruption might be so deep in Mexico that it would take 200
years to perhaps make a difference in it. It might be corrupt till doomsday.We cannot fix our own ghettos. We cannot fix Iraq or Afghanistan, so how can we imagine we can fix Mexico?
Wall Street is beyond the reach of American Law. Mexico will be beyond the Law too.
There are no plans (that I know of) for us to inhabit Afghanistan. Having Americans in Texas caused Mexico to begin changing, starting with independence from Spain, and eventually resulting in the separation of Texas. Americans in Mexico with USA support this time will be even more change agents.
Wall Street has been corrupt since colonial times (part of the reason the British stayed there during the Revolution). Considerable capital moved to New York City from the other 12 States based on a tip to investors by Alexander Hamilton in George Washington's Administration which helped Wall Street become a strong financial center. However, its control of USA commerce, thought, and politics has been diminishing since the capitol was moved to Washington DC and that trend continues to this day.
Many of the things we want to improve (and complain about) in the USA work quite well compared to other nations. That is no reason to stop improving; our areas needing improvement are no reason to back off of our expansion; and expansion could help us improve.
.